When deciding on a new puppy, one of the first things you need to consider is which breed will best fit your lifestyle. It’s important to think about exercise requirements, companionship, and how the dog will fit into your home life. While there are many different breeds to choose from, many dogs within a breed come from either a working line or a show line, and understanding the difference can help ensure that your new puppy meets your needs.
In 2020, a survey of British dog owners found the most popular breeds included:
However, what the survey doesn’t reveal is which lines these dogs come from—something critical to understanding their behavior and needs.
Labradors are the UK’s most popular breed, but there’s a significant difference between the working and companion lines. Working Labradors are lean, fast, and focused, with high energy and a strong need for mental stimulation. Companion Labradors, on the other hand, tend to be more laid-back, heavier set, and more food-driven. The working lines require a lot of physical and mental exercise to thrive, while the show lines are generally more relaxed.
Unfortunately, with their popularity, many Labradors now suffer from genetic health issues, like elbow dysplasia. Choose a breeder carefully to ensure you’re getting a healthy dog.
A mix between a Cocker Spaniel and a Poodle, Cockerpoos are a popular choice for families with children. While there’s no specific working or show line distinction for this breed, it’s still worth considering the energy levels based on the parentage. If the parents come from working lines, expect a higher energy, more demanding dog. Grooming is another factor, as their coat requires regular care. Cockerpoos are known for being smart and playful but may suffer from separation anxiety.
The difference between working and show lines in Cocker Spaniels is stark. Working Cockers are lean, high-energy dogs bred to work for long hours, while show Cockers tend to be more laid-back, heavier set, and less active. If you’re looking for an energetic dog that thrives with mental stimulation, the working Cocker Spaniel might be a great choice. However, these dogs require time, energy, and commitment. Show Cockers, being lower-energy, are better suited for a less active lifestyle.
Both types can be prone to hip dysplasia and ear infections, so proper care and a good breeder are essential.
Jack Russells, whether from show or working lines, are known for their tenacity and intelligence. Working Jack Russells tend to be smaller, more active, and focused on their work, while show Jack Russells are typically bred for appearance and are a little less energetic. Both types of Jack Russells can be challenging to train due to their high intelligence and independent nature. They are known to dig, chase, and bark, making them not the best choice for homes with delicate gardens or lots of noise-sensitive neighbors.
Jack Russells are prone to luxating patella (knee issues), so ensure you get your puppy from a reputable breeder who has screened for this condition.
One of the most intelligent breeds, Border Collies have a very strong need to herd. There’s a distinct difference between working and show Border Collies. Working Collies are bred for specific tasks on farms, where they excel in agility and herding. They are highly intelligent and require a lot of mental stimulation and physical exercise to be happy.
Show Border Collies are bred to meet the breed standard and may not have the same intense drive to work, though they are still intelligent dogs. If you don’t provide an outlet for their natural herding instincts, Border Collies can develop compulsive behaviors like tail-chasing or obsessive herding of inappropriate “prey” (such as cars or cyclists).
This breed isn’t recommended for families with young children or those living in townhouses, as their need for control and mental stimulation may cause frustration.
When choosing a dog, it’s crucial to consider whether its line—working or show—matches your lifestyle. Working dogs often require a lot of energy, training, and stimulation. Show dogs may be more relaxed but still have their own unique needs.
Every dog is an individual, but understanding whether you’re getting a dog from a working line or a show line can help ensure you choose the right breed for your family. Keep in mind that adopting a dog is a lifelong commitment. If you’re unsure about which dog to choose, consider rehoming a rescue dog, as this can be a rewarding experience for both you and the dog.
Before buying a dog, carefully evaluate whether the breed’s traits, whether working or show, align with your lifestyle. Make sure to choose a breeder who prioritizes the dog’s health and temperament to ensure a positive fit for your family. With thoughtful consideration, owning a dog can be one of life’s most fulfilling experiences.

























The Daisy Dog Academy
27 Ballynacoy Road,
Lisburn,
Co Antrim
BT28 3XW
Tel: 07919 305484
Email: info@thedaisydogacademy.com
Copyright © 2023 The Daisy Dog Academy. All rights reserved.
Site developed by ITsECPC